Responses to Recent Challenges and Public Attacks Against Materials in Libraries and Classrooms
Resources for Educators and Librarians
- American Library Association Fight Censorship Resources
- American Library Association: Working with the Media Toolkit
- CCBC What IF Questions and Responses:
- Importance of Following Policies and Procedures
- Holding Administrators and School Boards Accountable
- Importance of Considering Content in Context
- Questions about Diverse Materials
- Talking about Intellectual Freedom with Community
- Accusations of Providing Pornography
- Claims That Reviews Reflect “Liberal” Bias
- Concern Library Attempting to “Indoctrinate” Children
- Request to Purchase “Propaganda”
- Offering Support as Member of Community
- National Association of Secondary School Principals, “Banning Library Books in Public Schools: A Legal Primer” by Suzanne E. Eckes and Lauren K. Eckes” (May 2022)
- National Council of Teachers of English (NCTE) Book Rationales Database (for NCTE members)
- Online Harassment Field Manual (PEN America) (guide to dealing with online abuse)
- Utah Library Advocates: (Utah) Libraries as Keystone of Healthy Democracy, Student Success, and Prosperous Communities
Resources for Community Members
- American Library Association: Unite Against Book Bans Toolkit
- EveryLibrary.org provides pro bono consulting and offers a range of resources to help local advocates fight censorship
- FightfortheFirst.org, a project of EveryLibrary.org, helps local groups organize against censorship
- University of South Carolina/Penguin Random House/Ebsco: “Get Ready, Stay Ready: A Community Action Toolkit for Parents and Caregivers”
Professional Statements
- American Library Association Statement on Censorship of Information Addressing Racial Injustice, Black American History, and Diversity Education (August, 2021)
- American Library Association Statement in Opposition to Recent Censorship Attempts Targeting Marginalized Voices (December, 2021)
- Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction:
- WEMTA Statement in Support of School Libraries and Librarians (Wisconsin Educational Media & Technology Association)
- Wisconsin Library Association Statement on the Freedom to Read and Intellectual Freedom (June 2022)
Articles, Interviews and News
- BookRiot Censorship News Roundup
- “The Lives Upended by Florida’s School Book Wars” by Reshma Kerpalani and Hannah Natanson (Washington Post, December 21, 2023)
- “Book Removals May Have Violated Students’ Rights Education Department Says” by Elizabeth A. Harris and Alexandra Alter (New York Times, May 22, 2023)
- “Florida School District Is Sued Over Book Restrictions” by Elizabeth A. Harris and Alexandra Alter (New York Times, May 17, 2023)
- “The Freedom to Read and Learn: Educators Respond to Book Bans” by Brenda Alverez. (NEA News, January 31, 2022)
- “Here’s What Book Banning Means for Latinx Communities” by Meg Medina (Parents, April 1, 2022)
- “Legal Issues Involved in Reviewing School Library Materials.” Wisconsin Association of School Boards (Wisconsin School News, September 2023)
- “Once More for Those in the Back: Libraries Are Not Neutral” by Nicole A. Cooke, Renate Chancellor, Yasmeen Shorish, Sarah Park Dahlen, Amelia Gibson. (Publishers Weekly, June 10, 2022)
- “Teacher Voice: How the Shadow of Book Banning Shuts Down Conversations and Lacerates Librarians” by Tim Donohue. (Hechinger Report, September 12, 2022)
- “Thank You to America’s Libraries for Protecting Our Freedom to Read” by Barack Obama (Medium.com, July 17, 2023)
- “What To Do When Your Kid Is Reading a Book That Makes You Uncomfortable” (interview with Gender Queer author Maia Kobabe) (SLATE, March 22, 2022)
- Wisconsin Association of School Boards: Setting Library Policies
- “Windows, Mirrors and Glasses: On Seeing the World Through Diverse Books” by Grace Lin (Publishers Weekly, August 18, 2022)
- “Young People Have a Right to Stories That Help Them Learn” by Ashley Hope Pérez (NPR “Perspective, December 14, 2022)
Selected Professional Statements and Resources on Intellectual Freedom
- Library Bill of Rights and its Interpretations (American Library Association)
- Freedom to Read Statement (American Library Association)
- Children’s Right to Read statements (International Literacy Association)
- Academic Freedom and the Social Studies Teacher (National Council for the Social Studies)
- Academic Freedom position statement (National Council of Teachers of English)
- Students’ Right to Read (National Council of Teachers of English)
- WEMTA Statement in Support of School Libraries and Librarians (Wisconsin Educational Media & Technology Association)
- Wisconsin Library Association Intellectual Freedom Toolkit
- Position Statement on Intellectual and Academic Freedom (Wisconsin State Reading Association)
Policies and Procedures: Selected Guidelines
One of the strongest defenses against censorship is having board-approved (school board, library board) policies and procedures in place. Ideally these provide broad guidance for librarians and teachers in choosing materials based on the purpose of the collection or the goals of the curriculum, and outline specific steps to be followed in case of a complaint. Models that embrace these ideals include:
Libraries:
- Public Libraries: Sample Library Policies and Policy Resources (Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction)
- All Libraries: Selection and Reconsideration Policy Toolkit (American Library Association)
Classrooms:
- Guidelines for Selection of Materials in the English/Language Arts Program(National Council of Teachers of English)
- How to Write a Rationale (SLATE Starter Sheet, National Council of Teachers of English)
Privacy
Privacy as a core value: resources and links (American Library Association)
School libraries and privacy: resources and links (American Library Association)
Privacy Field Guides (Institute for Museum and Library Services and American Library Association)
Self-Censorship
Self-censorship—when a book or other item isn’t purchased or made available due to fears of complaints or other repercussions, or due to personal dislike of the message or content of a work—is something that is difficult to acknowledge and to talk about. But it’s important that librarians and teachers do acknowledge it, and do begin talking to one another about their struggles and concerns. These are critical first steps to overcoming this silent form of censorship.
- NCTE Statement on Censorship and Professional Guidelines (National Council of Teachers of English)
- Not Censorship but Selection by Lester Asheim (American Library Association)
- Self-Censorship Survey (School Library Journal)
Advocacy Organizations
American Civil Liberties Union : The ACLU is the nation’s primary advocate of an individual’s civil rights and civil liberties as guaranteed by the US Constitution and the Bill of Rights. The ACLU is best known for its litigation efforts. The ACLU also assists with advice on how to handle the practical politics that surround attempts to have materials excluded from the public schools. (ACLU-Wisconsin)
Banned Books Week: This annual event celebrates the freedom to choose, the freedom to read, and the freedom to speak.
Comic Book Legal Defense Fund: This non-profit organization dedicated to preserving the First Amendment rights of the comics industry has a comics censorship bibliography, case files of censorship attempts in which they’ve been involved as First Amendment advocates, and news of current and ongoing cases.
Electronic Frontier Foundation: This non-profit organization advocates for freedom of speech and privacy witih regard to digital technologies. EFF does much of its work in the courts, but also works in the area of policy analysis and education. The Deeplinks blog is a great way to stay on top of technology news as it relates to intellectual freedom and privacy.
EveryLibrary.org: This is a non-profit is a national political action committee for libraries whose efforts have included SaveSchoolLibraries.org, support and guidance for advocates for library ballot initiatives around the country, and building a nationwide advocacy network around library issues for citizens support.
Freedom Forum: The Freedom Forum is “dedicated to free press, free speech and free spirit for all people.” Among its initiatives are the Newseum, newsroom diversity, and First Amendment issues, which are emphasized through many education initiatives.
Freedom to Read Foundation (FRTF): The FTRF is the First Amendment legal defense arm of the American Library Association (ALA). The FTRF provides legal assistance and financial support in court cases involving the First Amendment and libraries.
National Coalition Against Censorship (NCAC) : The NCAC is an alliance of 50 national non-profit organizations that are united by a conviction that freedom of thought, inquiry, and expression must be defended. The organization works to educate its members and the public at large about the dangers of censorship and how to oppose them.
People For the American Way (PFAW) : The People For the American Way Foundation provides up-to-date news and information for policymakers, scholars and activists nationwide on the Religious Right movement and its political allies. PFAW also engages in legal action as needed to protect or restore the rights and liberties of Americans, as guaranteed by the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights.